Contested Privates : Religion and Homosexuality in Public Discourse

Publié le 4 octobre 2017 par Institut du Genre

Conference, October 26-28, 2017, Utrecht, the Netherlands

In public discourse in Europe, religion and homosexuality are increasingly seen as each other’s opposites, and seem to be caught in an apparently necessary, self-evident tension. This implies that religion and homosexuality are imbued with a specific, exemplary meaning in relation to each other in heavily polarized debates which are driven by (political) questions on (national) identity, social coherence and the recognition of cultural differences. This conference aims to investigate how this oppositional pairing functions in the representation and positioning of religious and/or sexual minorities in the Netherlands and other European countries. It is organized in the context of the NWO funded research project Contested Privates : the oppositional pairing of religion and homosexuality in public debates in the Netherlands (2013-2017), carried out at the Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam and Utrecht University.

One of the projects hypotheses is that the “discursive struggle” over religion and homosexuality is connected to shifting dividing lines and practices between what in modern societies is understood as public and private, and how in these changes religion and sexuality are situated. While religion was previously self-evidently present in the public domain, it is now referred to the private sphere. Homosexuality on the other hand, once a “matter of the bedroom”, has become more visible and the social and individual acceptance of homosexuality in Western countries has even become a prerequisite for claims to citizenship. This shift has covered a relatively brief time frame, and as of yet little is known about the role of specific national contexts and relevant institutions and movements. A second hypothesis is that the “discursive struggle” is connected to shifting dividing lines between what the terms religion, non-religion and secularism are supposed to entail. Modern/secular notions of sexuality (emphasizing individual choice, mutual consent and the fulfillment of everyone’s needs) are based on liberal starting-points such as freedom, equality, and autonomy. It is often assumed that these differ fundamentally from traditional / religious notions of sexuality, which would not be based on these same assumptions.

The guiding question of this conference is on which assumptions this representation of the current state of affairs is based, which conventions of religion, secularism, (homo)sexuality and gender differences are brought into play, and which social, cultural and ethnic differences between (groups of) people this oppositional pairing creates or confirms. The conference takes the historical and current political and religious configurations of debates in the Netherlands as its point of departure. The focus on the Netherlands derives, first, from the fact that this country has been known as a pioneer country when emancipatory legislation for LGBT persons is concerned (such as the introduction of same-sex marriage in 2001). This means that political debates on the relationship between religion and homosexuality, as well as academic reflections on these debates, have been ongoing for quite a while when compared to most other European countries. Moreover, the Netherlands have known a long-going discussion on the influence of “non-Western migrants” and “new religions” such as Islam on the social acceptance of homosexuality. This means that while in other countries research on ethnicity, religion and homosexuality is often conducted from underlying political norms such as laicity or shared citizenship (US), the Netherlands know more layered analyses of the role of (homo)nationalism, homonormativity and populism in contemporary debates on religion and homosexuality. On the other hand, theoretical disciplines such as queer theory and post-secular theory are underdeveloped in the Netherlands when compared to the United States, the United Kingdom and Scandinavian countries. This conference therefore aims to come to a fruitful exchange between the knowledge on ethnic diversity, sexual citizenship and right-wing populism developed in the Netherlands, and the innovative explorations into queer theory and post-secular theory in countries like the US and the UK.

The conference aims to provide perspectives from and on different European countries or regions as well as to provide reflections on the constructions of Europe and its others or allies.

We are happy to confirm the following keynote speakers :

- Prof. dr. Yvette Taylor, Professor of Education, University of Strathclyde, United Kingdom
- Dr. Roberto Kulpa, independent researcher in Queer Studies, Post-Colonial Theory and Nationalism, Plymouth, United Kingdom
- Dr. Erin Runions, Associate Professor and Chair, Department of Religious Studies, Pomona College, Claremont, California, United States.


20:00 Tea/coffee
20:30 Welcome and introduction to the conference (Ruard Ganzevoort)
20:45 KEYNOTE LECTURE Erin Runions : White Supremacy and the Child : Reproductive Futurity, Apocalypticism, Xenophobia 21:30 Discussion
22:00 Closing and drinks

9:00 Tea/coffee
9:15 Welcome and introduction
9:30 KEYNOTE LECTURE Roberto Kulpa : Un/likely Analogies ? Homophobia, Anti-Semitism, and Polish National Identity 10:30 PAPER PRESENTATION Ulrike Brunotte : Entangled Discursive Inventions : Queer Judaism and Jewish Inversion. Male Gender Crisis and German Nationalism,Around 1900

11:00 Break

11:30 PAPER PRESENTATION David Kurkovskiy : Homonationalist Discourses in Russian LGBT Activism and Western Coverage of Chechnya
PAPER PRESENTATION David Bos : Homosexuality and Islam in Dutch Public Discourse Since the 1960s
PAPER PRESENTATION Danica Igrutinovic and Mariecke van den Berg : Negotiating the New Serbia : State, Church and Blasphemy

13:30 Lunch


14:00 KEYNOTE LECTURE Yvette Taylor : ‘Queer Religious Youth : Contesting ‘Contradiction’ 15:00 PAPER PRESENTATION Lieke Schrijvers and Jelle Wiering : Religious and Secular ‘Good Sex’ : Empirical Accounts of Sexual Practices in the Netherlands

15:30 Break

16:00 PAPER PRESENTATION Paul Mepschen : Queer Muslim Organizing in the Post-Secular Netherlands
PAPER PRESENTATION Peter-Ben Smit : Dutch and Philippine Churches’ Reactions to Same-Sex Relationships in Comparative Perspective

18:00 Drinks
19:00 Conference Diner


9:30 Tea and coffee
10:00 PAPER PRESENTATION Ad de Bruijne : Culture Wars about Sexuality : A Theological Proposal for Dialogue
PAPER PRESENTATION Marco Derks : Religious and Sexual Regimes of the Self in Contemporary Public Discourses about Homosexuality in the Netherlands PAPER PRESENTATION Koen Rutten and Dana Theewis : Sexuality Education and a Politics of Exclusion

11:30 Break
12:00 Closing remarks by Marco Derks Korte and final discussion
13:00 Lunch